CHAYEI SARAH (Genesis, 23:1-25:18) — “Well, There’s Bad News and There’s Good News…”

The story is told about the cardiac patient who won the lottery.  His family members were afraid to tell him that he had just hit the jackpot, because they were concerned as to how he would react to the shock.  They called the cardiologist for advice.  “Doctor,” they asked, ‘how do we tell Dad that he just won 10 million dollars without putting a strain on his heart?”

The cardiologist put their minds at ease.  “Don’t worry,” he told them.  “I have been in practice for many years, and I know how to deal with people with weak hearts.  I’ll break the news to him gently.”

The next time the patient came in for a checkup, the cardiologist had a “theoretical” question for him.

“Mr. Goldstein,” he asked, “what you do if you won 10 million dollars?”

“Doc,” said Mr. Goldstein, “if I won 10 million dollars, I would give half of it to you.”

The doctor dropped dead!


It’s important to know how and when to give someone information.

Sarah lived until the age of 127.  Clearly not young, even by biblical standards.  Yet, we find that many people in her time lived longer.  Her husband Abraham lived till 175.  Isaac lived until 180, and Jacob lived a “mere” 147 years.

Sarah died shortly after the almost-death of her son Isaac.  Isaac, the carrier of Abraham’s legacy, had been bound to an Altar to serve as a burnt offering to G-d.   Just as Abraham was about to fulfill G-d’s command to sacrifice his son, G-d informed him that he was not to harm Isaac at all.  This had been a test of Abraham’s (and Isaac’s!) faith, and he had passed the test.

Rashi tells us that when Sarah heard about her son’s near-death experience, the shock killed her.

Rabbi Yerucham Levovitz observed that Sarah died too early.  She could have, and should have, lived longer.

How did Sarah hear about what almost happened to Isaac?  The Sifsei Chachomim, a commentary on Rashi’s commentary,  explains that a messenger came back to Sarah to report on the events that had transpired on Mount Moriah.

He told her how Abraham had arranged the wood pile under the altar, and how he had secured Isaac’s hands and feet onto the altar.  He described how Abraham had lifted the knife over Isaac for the coup de grâce.

The messenger was just about to tell her the rest of the story.  He was about to tell her about the Divine reprieve.  Unfortunately, he was too late.

 Isaac was the beloved only son of Sarah.  He represented the entire future of the Abrahamic dynasty.  Isaac was supposedly destined to carry on his father’s teachings to the rest of the world.  Isaac had no children; he had never married.  Who would carry on the legacy?!

Sarah was distraught.  She was beside herself with distress and grief over the about-to-be-reported demise of her son.  She died from the shock.


Rabbi Levovitz points out that Sarah needn’t have died.  The reporter messed up his report!  Had he told the story a little differently, the results could have been different.

Consider this approach:

Sarah – “What happened?  Where are my husband and my son?”

Messenger – “I have some wonderful news!  First of all, I want you to know that everyone is alive and well.  Everybody’s fine.  Now, let me tell you what happened.  It seems that your husband Abraham received a command from G-d…”


It would have made all the difference in the world.  Sarah, listening calmly, would have heard the ENTIRE story, including the fact that Isaac was saved.  She would have rejoiced in hearing that how righteous and self-sacrificing her son and husband were, without any loss to her and to our future.

Rabbi Levovitz points out that sometimes we think we’re doing someone a favor by telling them good news.  The problem is that if we don’t do it right, we’re not doing them any favors.

People have feelings; people have fears.  Sometimes simply talking to someone improperly can have devastating effects.  In Sarah’s case, information given over improperly caused a woman to die.

Know who you’re talking to.  Know their backgrounds and their sensitivities.  If you don’t know how to say something correctly, don’t just blurt it out.  When in doubt, say nothing.

Remember, the mouth bone is connected to the think bone… At least it SHOULD be.

Have a great Shabbos.

Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz

To leave a comment about this article, or to read other readers’ comments on this article, scroll down past the archive links.



 “Never Alone” (2016)

Isaac lost both of his parents…  First Sarah died.  Thirty-eight years later, Abraham died.

G-d paid a Shiva call.

And it was after the death of Abraham, that G-d blessed his son Isaac.  (Genesis, 25:11)

What was the nature of the blessing? And why does the Torah need to tell us that Isaac was Abraham’s son? Isn’t that obvious?

Read more.


“A Torah Jew’s Guide to ‘Losing’ Elections” (2012)

…Many of my friends are depressed and despondent.

They have waited four years …They tried. And they failed. And they are depressed.

And they are wrong…

Whenever I go to vote, I utter a prayer. I prayed this past Tuesday. What do you think I prayed for?…

Read more.


“The Living Dead or the Dead Living?” (2009)

… On September 11, he told his wife he loved her, told his friend to take care of her, recited a Psalm, and met his Creator. Hundreds of firefighters, policemen, and just plain civilians spent their final moments saving others.

On the last day of his life, Timothy McVeigh ate mint chocolate-chip ice cream…

Read more.


“Ham’s not Kosher!!” (2008)

Eliezer had a tough assignment.

Sarah was dead. Abraham was a widower with a 37-year-old unmarried son. The future of Abraham’s legacy was dependant upon Isaac marrying and raising the next generation of G-d-fearing “Jews.” It was imperative that Isaac marry a woman who shared his values. In narrowing the field of applicants, Abraham engaged in a bit of “racial profiling.” Canaanites need not apply…

This restriction affected Eliezer personally. This dedicated servant of Abraham had a daughter. He would have loved to have made a “Shidduch” between his daughter and his beloved master’s son. However, it was not to be. Eliezer, you see, was a Canaanite…

Read more.


“Well, There’s Bad News and There’s Good News…” (2006)

…when Sarah heard about her son’s near-death experience, the shock killed her.

… Sarah died too early. She could have, and should have, lived longer…

… Sarah needn’t have died…the results could have been different…

Read more.


“Will You Marry Me… Again?!” (2005)

… She was none other than Hagar, the mother of Abraham’s oldest son Ishmael. … as a result of Hagar’s idol worship, and her son Ishmael’s wickedness, they were both sent away.

Now that Sarah was gone, Abraham decided to remarry Hagar.

… How could Abraham do something like that? Where was his respect for his wife Sarah? … Now that Sarah is out of the picture, he goes back and marries this wicked woman??!!…

Read more.


“White Power!” (2003)

… Old age. A frightening prospect. As we age, we tend to slow down, in action as well as mental capacity. Society celebrates youth, and sometimes barely tolerates the old.

Wouldn’t it be great to be eternally young? Imagine advancing chronologically while our hair remains dark and our skin stays smooth. We’d put the hairdressers and plastic surgeons out of business! Wouldn’t it be wonderful?

Abraham didn’t think so…

Read more.


“Do You REALLY Believe That?!” (2002)

…What a beautiful story of faith and miracles! What a marvelous episode of Divine intervention and human acceptance of G-d’s will … What a LIE!!…

Read more.


“Walk a Mile for a Camel” (2000)

… Eliezer stood there watching to see if G-d had fulfilled his request … Why was he still wondering? Hadn’t G-d already shown him the sign? Eliezer requested that G-d show him Isaac’s bride by her offering to water the camels. The offer had been made! Why did he stand there and make her work so hard? DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW MUCH WATER TEN THIRSTY CAMELS CAN DRINK?!!!!!

Read more.


This is the weekly message at Copyright © 2000-2016 by Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz.  May be reprinted. Please include copyright information.


Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz is a Mohel ( and chaplain in Monsey,New York. For information about scheduling a Bris or a lecture, or just to say hello, call (800) 83MOHEL.


If you enjoyed this message, email it to a friend.

To subscribe to this mailing, send an e-mail to and type SUBSCRIBE on the subject line.

To unsubscribe, send an e-mail to and type UNSUBSCRIBE on the subject line.

Published in: on November 17, 2006 at 8:24 am  Leave a Comment  

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: