SHELACH (Numbers, 13:1-15:41) — “Fringe Benefits”

Isn’t it amazing that people can look at the same thing and see two different things?

Moses acquiesced to the requests of his People and sent twelve spies from the Paran Desert to explore the Promised Land.  The selected reconnaissance men were ranking members of their respective tribes.  Each was a distinguished, righteous man.  The 40-day mission concluded with a report to the nation. Two of the spies, Joshua and Caleb, eventually settled in the Land of Israel with the Israelites.  The other ten died in disgrace in the Paran Desert.

What had happened?  All twelve spies saw a land that flowed with milk and honey.  They all saw ample fruits and Canaanites.  The problems began when their respective minds drew very different conclusions from the information their eyes had provided. Joshua and Caleb saw a beautiful and holy land that G-d was prepared to give to them.  Their fellow scouts saw an aggressive Canaanite fighting force that would repel any Israelite efforts to inhabit the land.

Caleb and Joshua were in the minority.  The Israelites believed the negative reports of the majority and wanted to return to Egypt.  They feared for the welfare of their wives and children.  As a result, G-d decreed that they would get what they had asked for.  They would NOT enter the land.  Rather, the nation would wander in the desert for 40 years (one year for each day of the mission) until all of the adults who had rejected the Land of Israel had died. Only then would THEIR CHILDREN enter the land.

Amazing.  These people personally witnessed G-d’s ability to wreak havoc on the infrastructure of the powerful kingdom of Egypt.  Yet, they were afraid of a couple Canaanite nations?!!   They saw the Ten Plagues and the drowning of the Egyptian cavalry.  They knew what G-d was able to do for them.  Didn’t they realize that with G-d’s help THEY COULD EAT THE CANAANITES FOR LUNCH??!!!


Before answering this question, let us examine the end of this week’s Torah Portion.  There we find the Mitzvah of Tzitzis — fringes:

“. . . they will make Tzitzis on the corners of their garments . . . and put a strand of “T’cheiles” (turquoise wool) on the Tzitzis of each corner . . . You will see it and remember all of G-d’s Mitzvahs and fulfill them.  You will not stray after you hearts and your eyes that have led you to immorality in the past.”  (Numbers, 15:38-40)

How do the Tzitzis, these tassel-like fringes on the corner of a Tallisremind us to serve G-d?  One factor is the T’cheiles, the strand of wool that was dyed with the blood of the “Chilozon,” a marine animal whose identity is no longer known.  (Since we no longer know the identity of the appropriate source of this die, we make our Tziztzis with white strings only.  There are, however, some people who claim to have successfully identified the Chilozon, and have re-introduced this colored thread into their Tziztis.)  Gazing upon this turquoise thread reminds us of the sea.  The sea, in turn, reminds us of the sky, which is similar to sapphire.  Sapphire is similar to G-d’s throne, the reminder of which should serve to distance us from sin.   (Chullin, 89a)

Another way that Tzitzis keep us in line is through “Gematria,” or association by numerical value.  Every Hebrew letter has a numerical value.  The letters of the word “Tzitzis” add up to 600, which, when added to the eight strings and five knots on each corner, give a total of 613, the number of commandments in the Torah. (Rashi, verse 39)

In all due respect, both of these concepts seem to be a stretch.  Will color association and number games really keep us on the straight and narrow path, if we would be otherwise tempted to stray?

Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, of Blessed Memory, asked an additional question: The Torah requires us to attach these fringes only if we are wearing a garment that has four corners.  (For example, a Tallis or a poncho.) However, we are not technically required to put on such a garment if we don’t want to.  Strictly speaking, if we would choose not to put on the large Tallis that we wear in the synagogue, or the small Tallis that is worn under the shirt, we would be exempt from wearing Tzitzis. If the Mitzvah of Tzitzis is so important, why is it optional?

Rabbi Feinstein answered that Tzitzis are NOT an instant source of inspiration to those WHO CHOOSE NOT TO BE INSPIRED.  If we are inclined to be receptive to the message of the Tzitzis, we will look at the color and think of G-d’s throne.  If we possess the spiritual sensitivity to WANT to be inspired, we will do the math and come up with 613.  If, however, we are not looking for this message, we’ll see nothing but knotted blue and white strings.

Insisting that an uninterested person wear Tzitzis sends a message to a place where nobody’s home!


We can now understand the situation of Joshua and Caleb vs. the “Paran Ten.” The ten other spies weren’t interested in “making Aliyah.”  Therefore, it was very easy to come up with reasons why the Land of Israel was unassailable.  Where Joshua saw opportunity and G-d’s all-powerful hand, the others saw roadblocks.  Joshua and Caleb looked for G-d’s power and might, and found them.  The others looked for excuses and found them.

If we are open-minded and receptive to what G-d wants to tell us, we can see His influence everywhere.  A little blue string or a blade of grass is all it takes.  If we are not interested in what G-d wants to tell us, ten THOUSAND plagues won’t impress us.

When I was little boy, my parents used to take me to concerts to hear classical music.  It was a total waste of time and money.  (Sorry, Mom.) Had a connoisseur of classical music been in the audience, he might well have observed that it was a masterful performance.  I wouldn’t know.  I really wasn’t interested, and was therefore impervious to the delightful pleasures of experiencing a maestro’s talents.

We can appreciate all that G-d does for us if we are willing to pay attention.  Prayer can be uplifting or it can be tedious.  Torah study can be a revelation of the grandeur of G-d’s majesty. It can also be a purely cold and intellectual pursuit.  It all depends upon whether or not our “strings are attached.”


As I write this at 5 o’clock in the morning, my daughter is sitting outside.  G-d’s world is re-awakening. She is watching the swirling fog lift and listening to a concert of chirps and tweets.  “How,” she asks, “can anyone deny G-d’s presence in the world?”

Easily.  They’re sleeping.

Have a great Shabbos.

Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz

To leave a comment about this article, or to read other readers’ comments on this article, scroll down past the archive links.


From the Archives

“Fringe Benefits” (2010)

… Caleb and Joshua were in the minority.  The Israelites believed the negative reports of the majority and wanted to return to  Egypt.  They feared for the welfare of their wives and children…

Amazing.  These people personally witnessed G-d’s ability to wreak  havoc on the infrastructure of the powerful  kingdom of  Egypt.  Yet, they were afraid of a couple Canaanite nations!?!   They saw the Ten Plagues and the drowning of the Egyptian cavalry.  They knew what G-d was able to do for them.  Didn’t they  realize that with G-d’s help THEY  COULD  EAT THE  CANAANITES  FOR LUNCH??!!!

Read more.


“Around the Land in Eighty… um, FORTY, Days” (2007)

It should have been a longer trip.  G-d sped it up.

Twelve spies set off from the desert on a reconnaissance mission to check out the Land of  Israel…Unfortunately, as a result of the negative report by a majority of the spies, the Nation decided that they’d rather not go.   And, as the saying goes, be careful of what you wish for; you may get it.  G-d decided to postpone the move for a while.

…to walk the length and breadth of the Holy Land should take eighty days.  Miraculously, it took only forty.  And it’s a good thing.  The forty day “discount” saved us an additional forty years in the desert…

Read more.


 “I’m Gonna Do What You Want … Whether You Like It or Not!” (2004)

… Here’s where the story gets REALLY strange.  The Nation now realizes what a terrible mistake they just made.  G-d had said that they could have the Land.  They said, “No, thank You.”  G-d said, “O.K., never mind.”  Suddenly, they’re saying, “Now, wait a minute…”

Read more.


“Ten Times One Equals Infinity” (2003)

…  Why ask some strange rabbi to say Kaddish for my father when I can do it myself?!  This rabbi didn’t know and love my father the way I did.  Why should I let a stranger do what I should be doing?  So what if I can’t (read: won’t) go to Shul every morning?  Shouldn’t I be the one praying on behalf of my father?! …

Take nine of any righteous people you can think of.  Let’s say, for example, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Aaron, David, Noah, and your Uncle Sidney.  No Minyan.  You can’t say Kaddish or any of several other communal prayers …

Read more.


“What Was Moses’ Last Name?”  (2002)

… Caleb needed to get the attention of the mob.  How would he silence them?  He decided to pretend to insult Moses, calling him by his “last name” …

Why is it offensive to be addressed by one’s last name?…

Read more.


This is the weekly message at   Copyright © 2000-2012 by Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz.  May be reprinted. Please include copyright information.


Rabbi Yerachmiel Seplowitz is a Mohel ( and chaplain in Monsey, New York. For information about scheduling a Bris or a lecture, or just to say hello, call (800) 83MOHEL.


If you enjoyed this, send it to a friend.

To subscribe to Torah Talk, send an e-mail to, and type “Subscribe” on the subject line.

To unsubscribe, type “Unsubscribe” on the subject line.

Published in: on June 2, 2010 at 10:37 am  Comments (4)  

4 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. Question for the Oylm. By this Parsha, Sinai has occurred and almost all of the Mitzvos had been revealed. Many of those Mitzvas are related to Eretz Yisrael. Were the Meraglim m’chooyiv in those Mitzvos during their time in Eretz Yisrael?

    • For those readers who are less fluent in Hebrew expressions, I will take the liberty of “translating” your question.

      Some Commandments, such as separating tithes from produce, only apply in the Land of Israel. Your question, if I understand it correctly, is whether the 12 scouts who were sent by Moses to spy out the Land had to fulfill those Commandments during their mission.

      I don’t think so. The Mitzvah of separating Challah, for example, wasn’t even given to the Israelites until after the spies’ return, as we read at the end of this week’s Torah Portion. And that Mitzvah, unlike the other Israel-based Commandments would begin as soon as the Nation entered the Land, as opposed to other Commandments, which wouldn’t kick in until after the Land was settled. (See Rashi on 15:18)

  2. Suggestion for a title for your book, when it comes out: “With Strings Attached”.

    Shabbat Shalom

    • You’re KNOT kidding around! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: